Uncle Sam’s Fix for Civilian Surge: Forced Service?

Posted on June 22nd, 2009 by Kelley Vlahos

It shouldn’t be surprising that just a few months after hearing that the Obama Administration might not be able to fulfill its hopes for a “civilian surge” in Afghanistan due to a lack of interested/experienced American personnel, we now hear of Drug Enforcement Agency pilots being coerced — some say forcibly and illegally — into the war zone there.

According to an excellent report by Marisa Taylor at McClatchy Newspapers over the weekend, several DEA special agent pilots have obtained lawyers and are publicly charging the agency with forcing them to serve in Afghanistan. Those who have resisted put their careers in jeopardy. They also allege that pilots have been sent to Afghanistan as “punishment” by superiors, and when they do get there, they are ill-equipped (much like U.S military personnel at the start of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq).

This is disturbing on several levels. First, it’s becoming clear that Obama Administration has yet to get a handle on the endemic problems plaguing the DEA. Second, the administration seems intent on continuing this blind loyalty to the Drug War myth that has dumped millions of dollars and lives down a hole in Central and South America with ambiguous results (depending on your sources) at best, a swath of devastation across indigenous populations at the very worst. Third, there has been varying opinion on whether a U.S military-led drug eradication program within an (untested) counter-insurgency effort in Afghanistan will even work, or worse, will put the Afghan people more at risk and lead to declining security conditions for that already war-ravaged country.

In addition, is it even legal to force non-military federal personnel into war zone assignments? As Taylor’s story points out, this isn’t the first time we’ve heard about compulsory service for non-military personnel overseas in regards to the Global War on Terror. Considering the lack of volunteers, I’m sure it won’t be the last.

Finally — seeing that  Americans are now practically being Shanghaied to serve — isn’t time to have that serious debate over whether it is the U.S government’s role, much less the DEA’s responsibility, to be fighting drugs in other countries, in what a DEA spokeswoman called the agency’s “global mission?”

For sure, American demand fuels the drug trade in Afghanistan, but as we know, the Drug War here and abroad has been a bloody and expensive failure. Obama has acknowledged as much (sort of), but unfortunately, it’s clear now that he is resigned to reflexively pursue these policies overseas, plus, put  American lives (involuntarily) in harm’s way to do it.

3 Responses to “Uncle Sam’s Fix for Civilian Surge: Forced Service?”

  1. This is a prime example of the kind of Faustian bargain that so many federal employees make. They want all the job security, generous pay, and generous benefits that federal employment provides, they are a party to pro Big Government rhetoric ie “the DEA’s global mission,” but when Big Brother starts calling in markers, they call their lawyers.

    It seems to me they put themselves into this position. If they and others like them had voted libertarian, their current problem would be moot, because the DEA’s mission and scope would have ended at the essentials, (and at the border), instead of going global to justify its huge budgets. Instead, they pursued their own largesse, and consequently, Big Brother owns them.

    I doubt they will get much more sympathy than those who took ROTC funding but then never wanted to serve overseas or get deployed into war zones.

  2. At least one of your “facts” seems to be misleading:

    “For sure, American demand fuels the drug trade in Afghanistan…”

    According to:

    http://www.usdoj.gov/ndic/pubs31/31379/heroin.htm

    “Most global heroin production occurs in Southwest Asia, particularly in Afghanistan; however, relatively little of this heroin is destined for U.S. drug markets. According to U.S. Government estimates, Afghan opium cultivation accounted for approximately 94 percent (664 of 709 MT) of potential worldwide heroin production in 2006 (the latest full year for which data are available)…”

    “Most of the heroin produced in Afghanistan or Pakistan is destined for European and Asian markets. In fact, relatively little Southwest Asian heroin is transported to the United States…”

    Also, the real link to the Marisa Taylor article:

    http://www.mcclatchydc.com/227/story/70386.html?storylink=omni_popular

  3. Chris, all law enforcement officers find themselves enforcing laws they don’t agree with and following practices they find questionable. At some point they may have to quit as a matter of conscience. Few do.

    We can only hope that cops and soldiers retain a spirit of public service over chain of command. Otherwise they may eventually turn their guns on the rest of us.

Leave a Reply