We Guard The Maritime Border, We Guard The American Dream

Posted on September 25th, 2008 by Daniel Larison

Make it stop.

Update: Rod is a little underwhelmed:

She makes George W. Bush sound like Cicero.

I would like to imagine that the devoted fans of Sarah Palin, the people who believed her to be Reagan and Joan of Arc combined, who held out such hope for her as a future leader in the GOP and conservative movement, will be as irrationally and powerfully angry at McCain for putting her in the impossible position she is now in as they were enthusiastic about the selection of her in the first place.  As critical as I have been of her, I liked Palin too much to see her become McCain’s apologist and I still like her enough to wish that she could be spared all this.  Meanwhile, McCain’s election effort truly has become the MonDole campaign I once joked about. 

Second Update: Please, please, make it stop.

Third Update: One point in Palin’s defense.  She was defending the ridiculous claim that being near Russia affords foreign policy experience (yeah, and maybe growing up in the same city as Sandia Labs as a kid gives me the necessary experience to run NORAD), and as part of that she made a remark about Putin and airspace that wasn’t terribly clear.  As some of us know, the Russians have begun resuming long-range bomber flights over the Pacific and Arctic as another one of their P.R. demonstrations of resurgent military power, and the Russian planes are intercepted and escorted by American or NATO jets when they approach U.S. and Norwegian airspace respectively.  That is what Palin was semi-correctly, but confusedly referring to, so that is one thing that she got partially right.  Of course, as governor she has nothing to do with any of this, which just drives home how stupid the entire “close to Russia” argument is.  It is also guaranteed that is a Democrat from Alaska were on a national ticket, his relative proximity to foreigners would be considered proof of how marginal, out-of-touch and un-American he was.  The “close to Russia” claim is exactly the sort of dismissive, absurd thing that McCain’s people have to use, because you have to know that McCain’s advisors, most of whom are obsessed with foreign policy to one degree or another, find Palin’s lack of international experience even more horrifying than most journalists.  McCain’s own camp is so embarrassed about this that they have to concoct implausible connections between Palin’s role as governor and international affairs because they find her to be, to quote a certain ex-mayor, not cosmopolitan enough.

Fourth Update: Ross is not happy.

Fifth Update: Robert Schlesinger comments on Palin’s answer on the bailout:

It’s like a talking points machine gone out of control. Or magnetic poetry that you have on your fridge—in fact, you can try it at home. String together key words and phrases like “shore up the economy,” “reduce tax rates,” “healthcare reform,” and “trade” and see what kind of Palinisms you can create.

5 Responses to “We Guard The Maritime Border, We Guard The American Dream”

  1. Palin is a free agent. McCain didn’t foist her into the position she now finds herself in. She jumped at that chance, even though she was hopelessly unready from Day One. Were it not for her hubris and utter lack of self-knowledge, she would have realized that she was not fit for the job and declined it. It’s clear from her interviews, however, that she thinks she’s qualified to be a heartbeat away from the potential presidency of an old man with a history of serious cancer and other health issues. That kind of supreme over-confidence and overweening ambition makes it impossible for me to feel sorry for her now that she’s showing herself to be completely over her head. She bears a good deal of the responsibility for the spot she finds herself in; she accepted a job she should have known herself to be unqualified to assume.

  2. There’s no question that she’s responsible for her decision to accept the position, and if she really is as self-confident in her ability to fill that role as she claims to be that is a frightening lack of self-awareness. The point remains–McCain was the one who provided her with the opportunity to make this blunder, and anyone who was just enthusing about how amazing and great she was three weeks ago ought to be very angry with McCain for this decision. You don’t have to blame McCain, but at the very least I would expect the devotees to turn on him.

  3. What is she even talking about? Do you think she knows? Or is she trying to repeat what she was told to say, and failing miserably?

    http://www.entertonement.com/collections/4236/Palin-On-Issues-9-25-2008

  4. Agreed. They’re both to blame. I’m not a fan of either; I agree with Sullivan as to her capacities. She was a reckless choice on McCain’s part, chosen with very little vetting to determine whether she was ready for the position. I’ve gone through far more strenuous job interviews for far lesser positions. It says nothing for McCain’s judgment that he chose this know-nothing, intellectually incurious neophyte as his running mate. But it shows neither good judgment nor self-knowledge on her part to have accepted a position so clearly beyond her capabilities. McCain provided her with ample opportunity to show how out of her depth she is and she jumped at the opportunity.

  5. Regarding your third update, Daniel, I have some irony for you, courtesy of Josh Marshall at TPM:

    http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2008174647_palinrussia12m0.html

    Yes, it seems that the whole “proximity to Russia” has indeed afforded Alaska gov’s the opportunity to be at least a bit player on the world stage…but unlike her predecessors, Palin demonstrated no real interest in that role…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.